Blooming Baby | Essentials for Every Age: Swaddles, Pacifiers

The Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies: A Guide to Natursutten and More

The Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies: A Guide to Natursutten and More

By Blooming Baby | Essentials for Every Age: Swaddles, Pacifiers | Published: 2026-08-23

Category: Buying Guides

Discover the best pacifiers for breastfed babies, including Natursutten options, and learn how to avoid nipple confusion while keeping your little one soothed.

Choosing a pacifier for a breastfed baby can feel like a high-stakes decision. Many parents worry about nipple confusion, latch issues, or whether a pacifier might interfere with their breastfeeding journey. The good news is that with the right information and the right product, you can offer your baby the comfort of a pacifier without compromising your nursing relationship.

In this guide, we'll explore what makes a pacifier suitable for breastfed babies, the science behind nipple confusion, and why natural rubber options like Natursutten are often recommended. We'll also share practical tips for introducing a pacifier to a breastfed baby and highlight some of the best choices available at Blooming Baby.

What to Look for in a Pacifier for a Breastfed Baby

When selecting a pacifier for a breastfed baby, the shape, material, and size are the most critical factors. Orthodontic nipples are designed to support proper oral development, but some babies prefer a round, symmetrical shape that mimics the breast more closely. The key is to choose a pacifier that feels similar to what your baby experiences during nursing.

Material matters too. Natural rubber is softer and more flexible than silicone, which many babies find more comforting and similar to a mother's skin. However, natural rubber can have a slight taste and requires more frequent replacement. Silicone is firmer, durable, and easier to clean, but some babies may reject it because it feels different.

Size is another consideration. A newborn-sized pacifier is typically smaller and lighter, making it easier for tiny mouths to hold. As your baby grows, you'll need to size up to ensure safety and comfort. Always check the age recommendations on the packaging.

  • Look for a one-piece design to avoid choking hazards.
  • Choose a shield with ventilation holes to allow airflow and prevent skin irritation.
  • Consider a shield that is slightly curved or contoured to fit your baby's face comfortably.

Understanding Nipple Confusion and How to Avoid It

Nipple confusion is a term used to describe a baby's difficulty switching between the breast and a bottle or pacifier. While some experts debate its prevalence, many lactation consultants recommend waiting until breastfeeding is well established—usually around 3 to 4 weeks—before introducing a pacifier. This gives your baby time to master latching and helps prevent early confusion.

When you do introduce a pacifier, do it at a time when your baby is calm and not overly hungry. Offer it after a feeding or during a sleepy moment. If your baby rejects it, don't force it. Try again another day or consider a different style. Some babies are more accepting of a pacifier that has a shape similar to the nipple they are used to.

It's also important to remember that every baby is different. Some breastfed babies take to a pacifier immediately without any issues, while others may never show interest. Trust your instincts and your baby's cues.

  • Wait until breastfeeding is well established before offering a pacifier.
  • Offer the pacifier when your baby is calm, not hungry.
  • If your baby refuses, try a different shape or material.

Why Natursutten Pacifiers Are a Great Choice for Breastfed Babies

Natursutten is a brand that stands out in the world of natural baby products. Their pacifiers are made from 100% natural rubber derived from the sap of the Hevea brasiliensis tree. This material is free from BPA, PVC, phthalates, and other harmful chemicals, making it a safe choice for your baby's delicate mouth.

The shape of Natursutten pacifiers is designed to mimic the natural shape of a mother's nipple during breastfeeding. This can help reduce the risk of nipple confusion because the pacifier feels familiar to your baby. The soft, flexible rubber is also gentle on gums and emerging teeth, which is a plus for teething babies.

Natursutten offers a range of options, including the round shield design, which is popular among parents of breastfed babies. The shield is made from the same natural rubber, ensuring that everything that goes into your baby's mouth is safe and non-toxic.

  • Natursutten pacifiers are made from 100% natural rubber, free from harmful chemicals.
  • The breast-like shape may help reduce nipple confusion.
  • Available in different sizes to grow with your baby.

Top Pacifier Picks for Breastfed Babies at Blooming Baby

At Blooming Baby, we carry a curated selection of pacifiers that are ideal for breastfed babies. One of our top recommendations is the Natursutten Round Shield Pacifier (Set of Two). This pacifier features a symmetrical, round nipple that closely resembles the breast, and the natural rubber material is soft and flexible. The set includes two pacifiers, so you always have a backup on hand.

Natursutten Round Shield Pacifier (Set of Two)
Natursutten Round Shield Pacifier (Set of Two)

Another excellent option is the Natursutten Glass Bottle Natural Rubber Nipples, which are perfect for parents who want a consistent natural rubber experience across both feeding and soothing. These nipples are designed to fit Natursutten glass bottles, but they also serve as a reminder of the brand's commitment to safe, natural materials.

Natursutten Glass Bottle Natural Rubber Nipples
Natursutten Glass Bottle Natural Rubber Nipples

If your baby is a bit older and you're looking for a pacifier that can double as a teether, consider the Natursutten line, which offers various shapes and sizes. Always choose the size that matches your baby's age to ensure safety and comfort.

  • Natursutten Round Shield Pacifier (Set of Two) – a top pick for breastfed babies.
  • Natursutten Glass Bottle Natural Rubber Nipples – for a consistent natural rubber experience.
  • Choose the right size for your baby's age to ensure safety and comfort.

Tips for Introducing a Pacifier to a Breastfed Baby

Introducing a pacifier to a breastfed baby can be a smooth process with a little patience. Start by offering the pacifier when your baby is relaxed, such as after a feeding or during a quiet moment. You can also try dipping the pacifier in a small amount of breast milk to make it more appealing, but avoid adding sugar or honey, which can be harmful to infants.

Some babies prefer a pacifier that has been warmed slightly under warm water (not hot) to make it more soothing. Others may prefer a cool pacifier, especially if they are teething. Experiment to see what your baby responds to best.

Remember that a pacifier is a tool for comfort, not a substitute for feeding. Always offer the breast first if your baby is hungry. And be sure to clean and sterilize the pacifier regularly according to the manufacturer's instructions.

  • Offer the pacifier when your baby is calm and not hungry.
  • Try dipping it in breast milk to increase acceptance.
  • Experiment with temperature (warm or cool) to find what your baby likes.

Finding the best pacifier for your breastfed baby is about understanding your baby's needs and choosing a product that supports both comfort and healthy oral development. Natural rubber options like Natursutten are a fantastic choice for many families, offering a safe, breast-like alternative that can help ease the transition. Explore the Natursutten collection at Blooming Baby to find the perfect pacifier for your little one.

Shop Related Products

Natursutten Glass Bottle Natural Rubber Nipples

Natursutten Glass Bottle Natural Rubber Nipples

$8.14 $11.00

Shop Now
Set of Two Natursutten Glass Baby Bottles (S,L)

Set of Two Natursutten Glass Baby Bottles (S,L)

$25.89 $34.99

Shop Now
Natural Rubber Starfish Teething Toy

Natural Rubber Starfish Teething Toy

$9.59 $15.99

Shop Now
Sleeping Baby Classic Zipadee-Zip Swaddle Transition - Fleece

Sleeping Baby Classic Zipadee-Zip Swaddle Transition - Fleece

$25.73 $38.99

Shop Now