Blooming Baby | Essentials for Every Age: Swaddles, Pacifiers

Pacifiers and Teethers: Choosing Safe, Non-Toxic Materials for Your Baby

Pacifiers and Teethers: Choosing Safe, Non-Toxic Materials for Your Baby

By Blooming Baby | Essentials for Every Age: Swaddles, Pacifiers | Published: 2026-08-23

Category: Buying Guides

Learn what to look for in safe, non-toxic pacifiers and teethers, from natural rubber to BPA-free plastics, and how to care for them.

When it comes to your baby's comfort and safety, choosing the right pacifier and teether is more than just picking the cutest design. These everyday essentials go straight into your little one's mouth, so the materials they're made from matter immensely. With so many options on the market, from silicone to natural rubber and various plastics, it can be overwhelming to know what's truly safe and non-toxic.

In this guide, we'll break down the most common materials used in pacifiers and teethers, highlight what to look for (and what to avoid), and share tips for keeping them clean and safe. Whether you're a first-time parent or just looking to upgrade, this information will help you make an informed choice for your baby's health and happiness.

Why Material Matters for Pacifiers and Teethers

Babies explore the world through their mouths, and pacifiers and teethers spend a lot of time there. That means any harmful chemicals or toxins in these products can be ingested or absorbed. Over the years, concerns have been raised about substances like BPA (bisphenol A), phthalates, and lead in baby products. As a result, many parents are now seeking out safer, non-toxic alternatives.

Choosing the right material isn't just about avoiding harmful chemicals—it also affects durability, texture, and how your baby responds to the product. Some babies prefer the firmness of silicone, while others love the soft, flexible feel of natural rubber. Understanding the pros and cons of each can help you pick the perfect pacifier or teether for your little one.

  • Look for products labeled 'BPA-free' and 'phthalate-free' to avoid common plastic additives.
  • Consider your baby's age and teething stage: softer materials may be better for younger infants, while older babies might need more resistance.

Natural Rubber: The Eco-Friendly Choice

Natural rubber, also known as latex, is derived from the sap of rubber trees. It's a renewable resource that is biodegradable and free from synthetic chemicals. Many parents prefer natural rubber pacifiers and teethers because they are soft, flexible, and have a warm, natural feel that mimics the texture of a mother's skin.

One excellent example is the Natursutten pacifier, which is made from 100% natural rubber. It's free from BPA, PVC, phthalates, and other harmful substances. Natursutten also offers a natural rubber teething toy, like the Natural Rubber Starfish Teething Toy, which is perfect for soothing sore gums. The starfish shape is easy for little hands to grasp, and the natural rubber is gentle on tender gums.

Natural Rubber Starfish Teething Toy
Natural Rubber Starfish Teething Toy

However, natural rubber does have some downsides. It can have a slight taste that some babies may notice, and it may not be suitable for babies with a latex allergy (though this is rare). Natural rubber also requires more careful cleaning and should be replaced more frequently than silicone, as it can degrade over time.

  • If you choose natural rubber, inspect it regularly for signs of wear, such as cracking or stickiness, and replace it immediately if you notice any damage.
  • Always check the label to ensure the product is made from 100% natural rubber, not a blend with synthetic materials.

Silicone: The Durable and Hypoallergenic Option

Silicone is another popular material for pacifiers and teethers. It's a synthetic polymer that is incredibly durable, easy to clean, and free from the taste and odor that natural rubber can have. Silicone is also hypoallergenic, making it a great choice for babies with sensitive skin or allergies.

When choosing silicone products, look for medical-grade or food-grade silicone that is BPA-free and phthalate-free. Many pacifiers on the market, including those from well-known brands, are made from silicone. For teethers, silicone beads and shapes are popular because they are safe to chew and can be easily sterilized.

One thing to keep in mind is that silicone is firmer than natural rubber, which some babies might not like. However, it's also more resistant to bacteria and can withstand high temperatures, making it easier to sanitize. If you're looking for a long-lasting option, silicone is a solid choice.

  • Check the packaging for '100% food-grade silicone' to ensure the highest safety standards.
  • Silicone teethers can be chilled in the refrigerator (not freezer) to provide extra relief for sore gums.

Plastics and Other Materials: What to Avoid

While many pacifiers and teethers are made from plastic, not all plastics are created equal. Some older or cheaper products may contain BPA, phthalates, or other harmful chemicals that can leach into your baby's mouth. Always choose products that are explicitly labeled BPA-free and phthalate-free.

Another material to be cautious of is PVC (polyvinyl chloride), which is often softened with phthalates. Avoid pacifiers and teethers made from PVC, as phthalates have been linked to health issues. Instead, opt for products made from safer alternatives like polypropylene or polyethylene, which are commonly used in BPA-free products.

For teethers, you might also come across wooden options. Wood is a natural, sustainable material that is free from chemicals. However, ensure the wood is smooth and free from splinters, and that any finishes are non-toxic and food-safe. Wooden teethers should be cleaned with a damp cloth and not submerged in water, as they can crack.

  • Always read the label carefully and avoid products that list 'PVC' or 'phthalates' in the ingredients.
  • When in doubt, choose products from reputable brands that prioritize safety and transparency.

How to Care for and Clean Pacifiers and Teethers

Proper cleaning and maintenance are essential to keep pacifiers and teethers safe for your baby. For natural rubber products, wash them with warm soapy water and rinse thoroughly. Avoid using harsh chemicals or boiling them, as this can cause the rubber to degrade. Silicone products can be sterilized by boiling or using a steam sterilizer, but always follow the manufacturer's instructions.

Inspect pacifiers and teethers regularly for signs of wear and tear. Cracks, tears, or sticky spots can harbor bacteria and pose a choking hazard. Replace them as soon as you notice any damage. Most manufacturers recommend replacing pacifiers every 2-3 months, and teethers as soon as they show signs of wear.

It's also important to have multiple pacifiers and teethers on hand, so you can rotate them and ensure one is always clean. Consider using a pacifier clip or a dedicated storage case to keep them clean when not in use.

  • Never tie a pacifier or teether to your baby's crib or clothing with a string, as this can cause strangulation.
  • For natural rubber, avoid prolonged exposure to direct sunlight, as this can cause the material to break down.

Top Picks from Blooming Baby

At Blooming Baby, we understand the importance of safe, non-toxic materials for your baby's essentials. That's why we offer a curated selection of pacifiers and teethers that meet the highest safety standards. Our Natursutten pacifiers are made from 100% natural rubber and are free from harmful chemicals, making them a top choice for eco-conscious parents. Pair one with the Natural Rubber Starfish Teething Toy for a complete teething solution.

We also carry a range of silicone teethers and pacifiers that are BPA-free and phthalate-free, ensuring your baby gets the best. Whether you prefer the softness of natural rubber or the durability of silicone, you'll find the perfect option in our store. Plus, our teething toys are designed to be easy for little hands to hold and gentle on sore gums.

Remember, every baby is different, so it may take some trial and error to find the pacifier or teether your little one loves. But with our safe, high-quality options, you can rest assured that you're making a healthy choice.

  • Consider buying a few different styles to see which one your baby prefers.
  • Check our website for bundle deals and discounts on pacifiers and teethers.

Choosing the right pacifier and teether is a decision that impacts your baby's health and comfort. By focusing on safe, non-toxic materials like natural rubber and food-grade silicone, you can provide your little one with soothing relief without compromising on safety. Always read labels, inspect products regularly, and replace them as needed. For a reliable and eco-friendly option, we recommend the Natursutten natural rubber pacifier and the Natural Rubber Starfish Teething Toy from Blooming Baby. Explore our collection today and give your baby the best start.

Shop Related Products

Natural Rubber Starfish Teething Toy

Natural Rubber Starfish Teething Toy

$9.59 $15.99

Shop Now
Natursutten Butterfly Shield Pacifier (Set of Two)

Natursutten Butterfly Shield Pacifier (Set of Two)

$15.74 $24.99

Shop Now
Natursutten Glass Bottle Natural Rubber Nipples

Natursutten Glass Bottle Natural Rubber Nipples

$8.14 $11.00

Shop Now
Set of Two Natursutten Glass Baby Bottles (S,L)

Set of Two Natursutten Glass Baby Bottles (S,L)

$25.89 $34.99

Shop Now